What Are Donor-Covered Fees — and Do They Work?

In the world of nonprofit fundraising and peer-to-peer giving, every dollar counts. Transaction fees—those small charges applied by payment processors—can chip away at the funds meant for your cause. Enter donor-covered fees: an approach that invites supporters to cover processing costs themselves, so your organization receives the full gift.

In this article, we’ll explore everything you need to know about donor-covered fees, from definitions and mechanics to best practices and accounting implications. Whether you’re weighing the pros and cons or ready to roll out this option on your donation form, you’ll gain the context and guidance to decide if it’s right for your organization.

Definition of Donor-Covered Fees

Fees

At its core, a donor-covered fee is simply an invitation for the donor to absorb the credit card or ACH processing costs associated with their gift. Instead of the nonprofit deducting, say, a 2.9% + $0.30 fee from every donation, the donor sees an optional “Add [processing fee amount] to help cover transaction costs” checkbox at checkout. By choosing to check that box, they agree to increase their gift by exactly the fee amount, ensuring that the nonprofit nets 100% of the intended donation.

This model contrasts with the traditional approach, where the organization pays the fee out of the donated amount. When every penny contributes to programs and services, many nonprofits view donor-covered fees as a practical way to preserve precious fundraising dollars. It also aligns with transparency: donors clearly see exactly how much goes toward processing versus programming

How Donor-Covered Fees Work?

Implementing donor-covered fees is simpler than it may first appear. Behind the scenes, your donation platform calculates the exact processing cost—either as a percentage of the gift or a flat per-transaction charge—and immediately factors it into the donor’s total. When a supporter enters their gift amount, the system automatically computes the fee (for example, 2.9% plus $0.30 for credit cards or 1% for ACH transactions) and then displays an optional checkbox beneath the gift field. That checkbox might read something like, “Yes, I’d like to cover processing fees so 100% of my gift goes to [Organization Name],” clearly inviting donors to cover the extra cost.

If a donor chooses to opt in, the platform adjusts the total accordingly—turning a $100 gift into $103.20, for instance, to cover a $3.20 processing fee. Once the donor confirms the gift, the full amount (gift plus fee) is sent through your payment gateway. During settlement, your organization receives the intended gift amount (in this example, the $100) in your bank account, while the processor deducts its fee from the combined payment. Because the donor has agreed to cover that fee, your net proceeds match the original gift amount.

Most modern fundraising systems include this feature out of the box, performing real-time calculations and presenting donors with a clear breakdown before they finalize their gift. This transparent approach ensures supporters understand exactly how their contribution—and their choice to cover fees—impacts your organization’s bottom line.

Advantages of Donor-Covered Fees

When you invite donors to cover fees, several benefits can emerge—both financial and relational. Let’s look at some of the top advantages:

  • Preserves Program Dollars: By shifting processing costs to the donor, your nonprofit retains the full gift amount, maximizing the impact of every donation.
  • Transparent Fundraising: Clearly itemizing fees builds trust. Donors appreciate knowing exactly where their money goes and that their entire contribution supports the mission.
  • Higher Net Revenue: Studies and reports often show that when the option is presented, a substantial proportion of donors choose to cover fees—often 60–80%—leading to significantly more net funds raised.
  • Donor Empowerment: Offering the choice empowers supporters to make a direct decision about covering costs, which can enhance their sense of ownership and engagement.
  • Offset of Rising Costs: As processing fees creep upward—especially with new payment methods—donor-covered fees help nonprofits stay ahead of rising operational expenses without cutting into programs.

Together, these advantages can turn a small checkbox into a powerful tool for nonprofits of all sizes, boosting sustainability and reinforcing donor relationships.

Potential Drawbacks and Risks

Fees

No fundraising strategy is without its trade-offs, and donor-covered fees are no exception. It’s important to understand the potential pitfalls before rolling out this option:

  • Donor Hesitation or Drop-Off: Some donors may balk at covering additional costs, perceiving the ask as nickel-and-diming. This could lead to lower completion rates or smaller average gifts if the option is framed poorly.
  • Complexity of Messaging: Explaining donor-covered fees clearly and concisely can be challenging. Overly technical language may confuse donors, while vague phrasing can erode trust.
  • Platform or Technical Limitations: Not every payment processor handles added fees smoothly. Relying on multiple giving channels (website, mobile app, events) can complicate consistent implementation.
  • Regulatory Considerations: In some jurisdictions, surcharging—or adding extra fees—on credit card transactions is restricted or prohibited, even if the donor consents. Nonprofits must ensure compliance with both state and card-network regulations.
  • Accounting and Reconciliation Hurdles: Tracking and reporting on donor-covered fees adds complexity to bookkeeping. Without clear procedures, finance teams may struggle to reconcile gross amounts, fees collected, and net revenue.

While these risks aren’t insurmountable, they underscore the need for thoughtful planning, clear communication, and robust internal processes whenever you introduce donor-covered fees.

Impact on Donor Behavior and Revenue

How donors respond to the option of covering fees can vary widely based on factors like mission, donor demographics, and presentation style. Several studies have shed light on typical patterns:

  • Opt-In Rates: Nonprofits often see between 50% and 80% of donors opting to cover fees. Higher rates tend to occur when donors feel a strong emotional connection to the cause or when the fee amount is presented as a modest percentage of the gift.
  • Average Gift Size: Some organizations report slight increases in average gift amounts when donors cover fees—likely because the added cost feels minor in comparison to the impact of the contribution.
  • Conversion Rates: If the opt-in messaging is unclear or the added cost feels abrupt at checkout, conversion rates can dip. Optimizing language and testing placement can mitigate this risk and often restore or improve completion rates.
  • Donor Trust and Loyalty: Transparent communication about fees tends to bolster trust. Donors appreciate upfront disclosure, which can translate into stronger long-term engagement and higher lifetime value.

Ultimately, the financial impact goes beyond just fee recovery. By retaining full gift amounts and fostering donor goodwill, organizations can often increase overall revenue and deepen donor relationships over time.

Implementation Steps and Platform Settings

Ready to offer donor-covered fees? Follow these steps to get up and running smoothly:

Review Processor Policies

Before enabling donor-covered fees, it’s essential to conduct a thorough policy review with your payment processor or merchant account provider. Each gateway—whether Stripe, PayPal, Authorize.net, or another—maintains its own rules regarding surcharging or passing fees to payers. Credit card networks typically permit surcharging under strict conditions, but debit-card surcharges are often prohibited by law.

For instance, Stripe’s FAQ notes that while credit card processing fees can legally be passed on to payers, debit cards “cannot legally be charged a surcharge, while credit cards can.” Additionally, local and national regulations may cap maximum surcharge percentages and require explicit upfront disclosures to donors. Failing to adhere can expose your organization to fines, chargebacks, or account termination, and risk donor trust.

It’s also wise to check whether your contract includes nonprofit-specific pricing tiers or negotiated rates, as these can alter the effective surcharge levels you need to pass through. By meticulously verifying both contractual terms and legal requirements up front, you ensure a compliant, transparent process that protects both your organization and your supporters.

Choose Your Platform Features

Fees

Once compliance is confirmed, map out every donation channel where you’ll offer donors the option to cover fees. On your website’s primary donation page, platforms like FrontStream’s Panorama provide a “Donor Covers the Fee” toggle that can be turned on or off per campaign. Peer-to-peer fundraising portals must incorporate the same checkbox logic on each individual fundraiser page, ensuring consistency across personal networks.

For mobile giving, solutions such as Donorbox’s mobile plugin include an integrated fee-coverage switch positioned directly beneath the gift amount—optimized for small screens and touch interfaces. If you leverage text-to-give via SMS shortcodes, configure the final confirmation prompt in your SMS workflow so donors can opt in to cover processing costs without violating TCPA guidelines.

Auditing each giving channel for uniform branding, language, and placement will help donors recognize and respond to the fee-coverage option wherever they choose to give.

Configure Fee Calculations

Accurate fee calculations are critical: if your platform over- or under-charges, it can lead to donor frustration or accounting headaches. Begin by inputting the exact rates your processor charges for each payment method into your donation platform’s settings. Credit cards commonly incur a percentage plus flat fee—e.g., Visa and Mastercard at 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction—while premium cards like AmEx often carry higher percentages (for example, 3.5% + $0.30). For ACH or direct-bank transfers, many processors apply a 1% fee up to a capped amount or a fixed $1.00 fee.

Vendors such as Virtuous detail these rates in their admin panels (e.g., Visa 2.9% + $0.30; AmEx 3.5% + $0.30; ACH 1% + $0.50). Stripe’s pricing page further highlights add-on surcharges—like 0.5% for manually entered cards or 1% for currency conversion—that must be accounted for separately. By configuring each fee bracket distinctly, your system will automatically append the precise fee to donor totals when they opt in, avoiding rounding errors or discrepancies in your financial reports.

Design Opt-In Checkbox

The opt-in checkbox should be both inviting and unobtrusive. Use donor-centered language that emphasizes impact—phrases like “Help my gift go further by covering processing costs” outperform technical terms such as “transaction fee.” Never pre-select the checkbox; requiring an active click builds trust by ensuring donors consciously choose to cover fees.

Position the checkbox immediately below the gift-amount field, in a font size and style consistent with the rest of your form, so it’s visible without distracting from the donation flow. Accompany it with a brief explanation or tooltip—“Adding 3% helps us maximize your gift for [cause]”—to reinforce generosity rather than obligation.

Finally, conduct quick qualitative tests, such as user interviews or heatmapping, to confirm that the language and placement resonate with your audience and do not introduce friction into the giving process.

Test Scenarios

Before going live, leverage your platform’s test or sandbox mode to simulate a variety of gift scenarios without real money changing hands. For example, FundraisingBox’s “Test Mode” lets you trace every step of a donation flow. Execute dummy transactions at multiple gift levels—small (e.g., $10), medium (e.g., $100), and large (e.g., $1,000)—using each payment method (credit, debit, ACH).

During each test, verify that the opt-in fee calculation adds the correct fee percentage and flat amount, that the updated total is clearly displayed on confirmation screens, and that receipts preview the fee breakdown accurately. Test across browsers (Chrome, Safari, Firefox) and on mobile devices to catch any UI inconsistencies or rounding discrepancies.

Additionally, consider an A/B test—splitting traffic between the new fee-coverage flow and a control version—to measure impacts on conversion rates and donor behavior. Document and resolve any anomalies before launch.

Update Confirmation and Receipts

Post-donation transparency cements donor trust. Your confirmation emails and receipts should itemize three line items: the gross gift amount, the exact fee covered, and the net donation directed to your programs. According to best practices, gift fees must be disclosed in gift agreements and receipts to ensure donor awareness and full disclosure. Platforms like Stripe treat covered fees as part of the donor’s gross contribution, so your receipts should reflect this by showing the gross total—including fees—as the charitable gift value. A sample receipt might read:

Total Gift: $103.00

Processing Fee Covered: $3.00

Net Donation: $100.00

Adding a short thank-you note—“Thank you for covering processing fees! Your support ensures 100% of your intended gift advances our mission”—reinforces transparency and appreciation, while streamlining your year-end reporting and tax acknowledgement workflows.

Train Your Team

Equip all staff, call-centerers, and event volunteers with consistent messaging around donor-covered fees. Develop a concise FAQ sheet that defines fee coverage, explains why it matters, and outlines how fees are calculated. Train staff on how to answer common questions—“Is this mandatory?”, “How does this affect my gift?”—using the same donor-friendly language on your donation form. Industry guidelines stress the importance of educating staff so they can explain surcharge policies and maintain donor confidence.

If you’re also using text-to-give, integrate TCPA compliance training to ensure staff can address SMS inquiries without regulatory risk. Incorporate role-playing scenarios—such as a prospective donor at an event kiosk or a supporter calling in—to build comfort and consistency. Well-trained team members become ambassadors for your cause, safeguarding donor trust and optimizing opt-in rates.

With these steps complete, you’ll be ready to welcome donors into the process of covering fees, helping your organization retain more of every gift.

Best Practices and Testing Recommendations

To maximize the effectiveness of donor-covered fees—and minimize any friction—consider these best practices and testing tactics:

  • Keep Language Simple: Use clear, conversational explanations. For example: “Help us cover processing costs so 100% of your gift supports our mission.”
  • Highlight the Impact: Remind donors what their fee covers. A brief parenthetical like “(this small addition saves us $3 on fees for a $100 gift)” conveys the benefit.
  • Position Near Total: Place the checkbox immediately after the gift amount to ensure donors see the option before proceeding.
  • A/B Test Messaging: Experiment with phrasing—emphasize choice (“Would you like to…?”) versus statement (“Add fees to support us”).
  • Test Checkbox Defaults: Industry best practice is to leave the checkbox unchecked by default (opt-in), respecting donor autonomy. Some organizations test a pre-checked box, but this can raise ethical or compliance concerns.
  • Monitor Metrics Closely: Track opt-in rates, average gift amounts, and completion rates. If you notice a dip in conversions, revisit your copy or reposition the opt-in.
  • Gather Donor Feedback: Include a short, one-question survey in post-donation communications asking donors about the clarity of the fee option. Use this insight to refine your approach.

By iterating and learning from real-world data, you’ll discover what resonates best with your audience and maximize net revenue without alienating supporters.

Accounting and Reporting Considerations

Introducing donor-covered fees creates new accounting nuances. To keep your books clean and compliant, follow these guidelines:

  • Separate Revenue Streams: Record gross donations and fee reimbursements in distinct ledger accounts. That way, you can clearly report total program revenue and separate income from fee recovery.
  • Reconcile Fees Monthly: Match the fees collected from donors against the fees charged by your processor to ensure accuracy. Discrepancies may indicate configuration errors or failed transactions.
  • Update Donation Memos: Ensure your accounting software captures the donor’s intended gift amount as the primary revenue, with the fee reimbursement logged separately. This helps maintain consistency in donor reporting and gift acknowledgment.
  • Generate Custom Reports: Create monthly or quarterly reports that show gross donations, fees recovered, net revenue, and opt-in percentages. These metrics will inform future budgeting and strategy discussions.
  • Review Tax Implications: In most jurisdictions, transaction fees covered by donors are not tax-deductible as charitable gifts (since they’re viewed as payment for services). Inform donors in receipt language, and work with your finance team or auditor to ensure compliance.

A transparent, well-documented accounting process not only keeps your nonprofit in good standing but also provides the data needed to make informed fundraising decisions.

Alternative Approaches and Donor Communication

While donor-covered fees can be powerful, they’re not the only way to manage transaction costs. Consider these alternatives or complementary strategies:

  • Incorporate Fees into Campaign Budgets: Build estimated processing costs into overall fundraising targets. For example, if you expect to raise $100,000 at a 3% fee rate, set your goal at $103,000 to compensate.
  • Offer Flat-Fee Giving Levels: Instead of percentage-based fees, present giving tiers that include a built-in flat fee. This can simplify messaging for certain campaigns.
  • Encourage Bank Transfers: ACH or direct-debit transactions often carry lower fees. Promote these options by explaining the savings and providing easy-to-use forms.
  • Negotiate with Your Processor: If your nonprofit has substantial volume, ask your merchant services provider for discounted fee rates or nonprofit pricing tiers.
  • Communicate Impact Transparently: Whether you use donor-covered fees or not, regularly share reports on how transaction fees affect your budget and program delivery. Transparency fosters trust and may prompt donors to seek lower-cost giving methods.

Whatever path you choose, keep donors informed—explain why fees matter, how they affect your work, and what steps you’re taking to maximize the impact of every gift.

Conclusion: Do Donor-Covered Fees Work?

So, do donor-covered fees work? In most cases, the answer is yes—provided they’re implemented thoughtfully. When donors clearly understand the option, a significant majority opt in, boosting net revenue and reinforcing a spirit of shared ownership. However, success hinges on transparent communication, careful testing, and robust accounting practices.

By evaluating your audience, platform capabilities, and compliance requirements, you can craft an approach that maximizes funds for your mission without compromising donor trust. Ultimately, donor-covered fees are not a silver bullet, but they are a powerful tool in the fundraising toolbox—one that, when wielded with care, can help your nonprofit thrive and better serve those who depend on you.